🔗 Share this article

Mark Lee Gardner, a notable scholar of the American frontier, has authored a new publication titled Gunfighters United, which examines the lives of the famed lawman and the notorious gambler. The historian notes frustration with the famous phrase from a iconic movie: “When the tale becomes reality, print the tale.”

“Every writer quotes it, they just repeat it endlessly,” he comments cheerfully. “And it’s truly not correct. I composed a account. I want people to be immersed in the time, but I just get so weary of that line. The myth is myth. It won't become truth. People can retell the legend but it won't make it reality.”

The Infamous Showdown at the O.K. Corral

In Tombstone, Arizona, on a day in October 1881, Wyatt Earp and Holliday were took part in a confrontation that came to be known as the Gunfight at the OK Corral. Alongside Earp’s brothers, the pair met the rustlers, members sought for robbery and rustling. In less than a minute, three Cowboys were slain and Doc was hurt, as were Virgil and Morgan Earp.

Although being one of countless frontier conflicts between lawmen and outlaws, it became legend, partly thanks to famous pictures including My Darling Clementine and another renowned film.

Uncertainty and Variation in Eyewitness Testimonies

“A great deal of what we learn about it is confirmable,” the historian noted of the true fight and its aftermath. “But I consistently go back to one of the most telling quotes, and it’s a very simple quote. A dressmaker, who witnessed the confrontation, said: ‘I don’t know. Everything was chaotic.’”

Including the people there had varying stories. Testimony from the investigation is also unclear. Observers who were associates of the gang were untruthful, and every story is a bit unique. It’s rare when anyone agrees on anything.

“Everything was chaotic.” – Addie Borland

“Including the participants there were uncertain,” he adds. “So it’s really hard to get at it, and it occurred in half a minute.”

Legend-Building and Film Depictions

Wyatt Earp survived into the Hollywood period, dying in the late 1920s at the years of eighty. First shown on a early cinema screen in 1923, he eventually became the subject of major 20th-century westerns. In relatively contemporary times, he has been portrayed by an actor in Tombstone and Kevin Costner in Wyatt Earp.

Gardner drills through such storytelling to uncover the individuals beneath. His works span the range of the American frontier, from Billy the Kid and the sheriff to the notorious bandit.

Layered Lives of Earp and Holliday

Originating in the Midwest in 1848, Wyatt was underage to participate in the civil war, though he sought to do so. When he was 20, he became a constable in a small town. Mistakes were made. He suffered a calamity with the death of his partner, Urilla Sutherland, from illness in 1870. Afterward, as a official, he held onto revenue he collected.

“We do not know why he held it,” he says. “He runs, and arrives in the frontier. He’s arrested for stealing a horse, and then he’s in Illinois, and he’s operating a bawdy house. In time he travels back west, and he arrives in a booming town.”

Regardless of his troubled past, Wyatt performed well as a lawman. Local papers applauded him repeatedly. In one instance, he arrested a inebriated man who had $500 on him. Earp secured the money for the individual and handed it back when he freed him from confinement.

Different Natures of the Partners

The historian emphasizes the clear contrast between the two. Wyatt was aspiring, wanting to improve himself and reach positions like sheriff. Holliday, hailing in Griffin, Georgia in 1851, was a tooth doctor turned gambler. Different from Earp, Holliday didn't exhibit signs of settling down.

“Holliday just moves from one gambling place to the next one,” Gardner says. “He doesn't truly transform. And some of that’s his dependence to betting. Part of that is consumption, managing that and treating himself, whether it’s with whiskey or subsequently medicine.”

Impact and Scholarly Relevance

This volume illustrates a compelling aspect of the frontier: the friction between law and lawlessness, and the efforts of officials to exert control over newly forming communities. The degree of paperwork that followed a gunfight – inquiries, affidavits, directives for compensation – might surprise those familiar with romanticized portrayals of the era.

Additionally, Wyatt and Doc were embroiled in partisan political struggles. He was a member of the GOP, while Tombstone sheriff a Democrat was a Democrat, creating a competition for power and authority.

Finally, the historian refuses to glorify these individuals. Wyatt and Holliday passed time on each end